I’m a LinkedIn Ghostwriter for life science executives among other things, and I know people in the industry ask me to write Thought Leadership.
That is exactly what happened in a recent meeting: someone mentioned wanting my help to create Thought Leadership content for several executives, and I hesitated. I said “I can ghostwrite, of course. Tell their stories. But I dislike doing Thought Leadership.”
This prompted confusion in the other party. They asked if that wasn’t what I did, that they had thought of me specifically for this. I thought about it and said that yes I can write Thought leadership but that people often mistake what that means.
The conversation lingered in my mind. I’m now trying to put together why I dislike the term Thought Leadership used so liberally.
For those of you not in the know, Thought Leadership refers to authority content in a specific niche, often positioning someone as a top authority or expert.
Now, before I get lynched, Thought Leadership is great… when done well. But with the advent of ghostwriters left and right, there is a tide of wannabee leaders that think that to be recognized they just need to post like they own their category, when often they are just up and comers, small fish in a small pond.
When a true leader and an exceptional ghostwriter collaborate on thought leadership pieces, the results are impeccable.
But what makes a true leader?
In my opinion, not their ideas or thoughts. Rather, it is their actions. Because ideas can be a dime a dozen, and only execution can let you know their true worth with accuracy. The true test of an idea is how well it stands after it has been acted on.
Now, many people want to claim to be thought leaders, to be pushing the boundaries of what’s possible in a given field, to be the foremost experience. These people are often early founders or executives in small or medium sized companies whose coin is still spinning, and whether their ideas are landing on heads or tails is still unknown.
Every time I have tried to meet these people’s wants of writing “thought leadership,” the results have been nothing to be too excited about. Not for lack of good writing, mind you! But rather because others know a boast when they see it.
But does that mean that these people have nothing to talk about? No, not at all. I have seen enormous results doing something much different: building in public, or how I like to call it when I’m feeling fancy: Action Leadership.
In fact, it is startup founders and people who are still building their tower of knowledge who do best at this, because being innovative requires you to DO things. And for people, to see you acting, building, and betting on your own ideas is much more refreshing and interesting than self-proclaiming yourself king of one niche or another.
And it’s often a much easier field to compete in. Actual thought leaders have dozens of wins under their belts to prove they not only talk the talk, but walk the walk. That is why, when they speak, people listen.
But most often these people are doing slower, more precise bets. There’s an unoccupied space for those who are taking the big risks and shots, and going all in on something that is yet to be tested.
Overall, I’d like to see more people talking about action rather than thoughts. What are you DOING about those thoughts, instead of just the take? I believe that is the content you should be publishing, not synthetic thought leadership.
You can call it building in public, you can call it storytelling, or you can call it Action Leadership. But from what I’ve done and seen, it goes further to be humble and grounded than to write hollow grandiose statements.
Want more LinkedIn content, straight to your inbox? I run a weekly newsletter where I help you write better posts, explain what I see working on LinkedIn, and more. Sign up here.